Judge Robert Freedman

RECENT POSTS

Gang injunction filings: defense attorneys seek mediation

Oakland City Attorney

Oakland's latest gang injunction would cover part of the Fruitvale district.

The defense attorneys in the NorteƱo gang injunction case have asked Judge Robert Freedman to direct both parties to mediation hearings that would limit the scope of the proposed court order.

Judge Freedman has yet to issue a ruling. Closing arguments in the Fruitvale injunction were held on May 6. Meanwhile, City Attorney John Russo’s last day in office will be June 10. A replacement has yet to be named by the Oakland City Council, and Russo’s successor will most likely be chosen during a special election later this year.

On May 17th, attorneys for the city noted that the defense’s May 13th deadline for filing revisions to the proposed injunction had passed with no submissions by the defense, and asked the court to approve the court order against 40 alleged gang members.

The defense’s brief, filed on May 27th, points to recent developments as grounds for moving the case towards mediation to possibly remove some defendants from the injunction, limit the size of the injunction area and modify some of the restrictions on the movements and associations of the named defendants. On May 18, the Oakland City council voted to continue with the North Oakland and Fruitvale injunctions, with some modifications and barred the City Attorney from proceeding with a third injunction until the strategy is independently evaluated. Continue reading

North Oakland injunction left intact; may be lifted in a year’s time

Puck Lo

North Oakland resident Margaret White speaks at Thursday's protest in front of the Alameda County Courthouse

A gang injunction against 15 alleged members of the North Side Oakland gang was upheld at a status conference yesterday in front of Alameda County Judge Robert Freedman. A vocal demonstration of about 80 people before the hearing and an amicus brief filed by the Stop the Injunction Coalition detailing the injunction’s impact on North Oakland residents did not convince Freedman that there has been any evidence of “untoward intrusion into the lives of citizens.”

Attorneys representing City Attorney John Russo’s office maintained that the injunction is working to date because the fifteen named individuals have been keeping a low profile and have not violated the injunction. Oakland officials have changed their position on whether the injunction is working a number of times. In response to a spike in North Oakland crime this summer, the City Attorney claimed it was too early to determine whether the injunction was working. At Wednesday’s announcement of a proposed gang injunction against the Nortenos, Police Chief Anthony Batts asserted the North Oakland injunction has been effective in controlling criminal activity. Continue reading